Debarking: A Controversial Procedure

By | February 8, 2010 9:34 a.m. EDT

Last week, the New York Times featured an article on a controversial procedure known as debarking. It was listed among the publication’s "most e-mailed” articles, so I know it drew some interest from their readers.

In the procedure, a veterinarian snips the vocal cords of a dog to prevent it from making a noise when it barks. Opinions stated in the article ranged from "it’s cruel” to "if it’s the only thing that can prevent a dog having to go to a shelter, it’s the right thing to do.” I thought I’d open up a conversation here on DogChannel to see what our readers think.

In the Times, one of the sources quoted said that de-barking cuts off a dog’s main form of communication. While I agree that the procedure is not ideal, I don’t believe this statement is true. In my experience, most of a dog’s communication is silent. Barking seems to be a last resort they use when their humans aren’t "getting it.”

I’m in favor of training to deal with barking and with keeping a dog in its natural state (aside from spaying and neutering), but if an owner has truly tried everything and the dog is just a barker and his neighbors are threatening to throw him out of his apartment building, I am glad this option is available. Those of us with dogs that don’t bark can criticize a person’s "failure” at training or assume they aren’t working as hard at it as they should be, but as a person with a 5-month-old puppy that has defied many of the "shoulds” in every training book, I can’t do so myself. A dog that can’t bark living with a loving family in a warm, happy home beats an abandoned dog barking his head off in a kennel at a shelter any day.


3 of 3 Comments View All 3 Comments

Give us your opinion Give us your opinion on Debarking: A Controversial Procedure

User Avatar

Stephanie   North Canton, OH

5/15/2010 6:41:16 PM

What a touchy topic.

User Avatar

Andrea   Crystal Springs, MS

2/10/2010 9:40:11 PM

How would u like it if someone cut out your vocal cords.

User Avatar

Beth   Lockport, NY

2/10/2010 4:24:05 PM

We rescued a smoothhair fox terrier who also is a retired champion. She needed a home and I could not believe what I found out. She had been crated for 5 years and not to annoy the owner she had her barker removed. I had never even heard of this before and to me it is like animal cruelty. Our smoothhair is loving her new home and enjoying her new freedom and her 2 scottie brothers.

Login to get points for commenting or write your comment below

First Name : Email :
International :
City : State :

Captcha Image

Get New Captcha

Top Products