Westminster and The Puppy Bowl

It’s that time of year again, The Westminster Kennel Club Show, when pure bred dogs from all over the country go paw to paw to take home the coveted prize of Best in Show.

By | Posted: February 13, 2012, 5 p.m. EST

It’s that time of year again, The Westminster Kennel Club Show, when pure bred dogs from all over the country go paw to paw to take home the coveted prize of Best in Show. I have gone to this show every year as a member of the press since 1999. It’s like the Super Bowl for dog lovers.

And speaking of the Super Bowl ... I have to admit that I have never watched a single Super Bowl. If the Miami Dolphins aren’t in it, which they haven’t been since 1984, I really can’t be bothered. But that’s not bad news for me because Animal Planet plays The Puppy Bowl in the same time slot, and I watch it every year – this year, I was one of 8.7 million other viewers who were taken with those precious puppy faces. The Puppy Bowl is endlessly entertaining – puppies romping and tumbling and scoring “touch downs” by taking toys into the “end zone.” It doesn’t get a whole lot cuter than that.

The thing that struck me this year in the Puppy Bowl was that most of the “players” were mixed breeds – mutts. This is different from years past, when many pure breed dogs took the field. I did a little research and found that all of the pups were rescue dogs and were up for adoption from 25 different rescues and shelters. Kudos to Animal Planet for encouraging adoption, especially of mixed breeds. I believe that many of the past years’ Puppy Bowl players were also up for adoption, but I don’t ever remember an “mostly mutt” team before.

Having volunteered in two shelters, I have seen how hard it can be to adopt out a “plain brown dog,” and black dogs have a challenging syndrome of their own. People seem to be drawn to purebred dogs, or those that seem to have a “primary breed.” Certainly the “doodle” phenomenon has been changing that a little. It’s “cool” now to have a Mixed Breed dog if you can add the word “doodle” to it somewhere. But when that dog goes to the shelter, it’s just a “mixed breed” again.

Whenever someone asks me what “breed” Pearl is, I always shrug and either say “mutt-from-the-pound,” or “I don’t know” – I say the latter when I want to hear what they think she is. One man said to me, “Oh, come on, she has to have a breed.” No, actually, she doesn’t. She’s a mutt from the pound. I have no idea what she is. It would be fun to know, but I don’t lose sleep over it.

Which brings me to The Westminster Kennel Club Show. There’s not a mutt or doodle in sight. There are perfectly quaffed Poodles and blown-out Briards, and breeds that you’ll likely only see at Madison Square Garden (not on your block), like the Entlebuckher Mountain Dog and the Cesky Terrier, two new breeds entered this year.

I have to say, mutts do rock. I live with one and she’s the source of endless joy for me. But I live with two pure bred Miniature Schnauzers too, and they are amazing. For me, a dog is a dog. I can get just as thrilled at watching mutts romp around the Puppy Bowl, or participating as a spectator in the second oldest sporting event in the United States (the Kentucky Derby is the oldest next to Westminster, but only by one year). I do know how controversial dog shows are – many people are adamantly against them, and some are against purebred dogs. I understand their arguments. But I still like The Westminster Kennel Club show.

I have interviewed dozens of show dog owners over the years, including several of the show’s winners. These dogs are not relegated to kennels, bred to exhaustion, and tossed out once they are used up. That’s what backyard breeders do. That’s what puppy mills do. Most of the dogs at Westminster live at home with the owners or handlers (who treat them like their own dogs), and live the good life of a pampered pet.

Just like us, these owners understand their dogs’ quirks, likes and dislikes, and cater to them just as we do. If a dog didn’t like being shown, that preference would be apparent in the ring and the dog wouldn’t place, much less win. And believe me, it’s not about the money for people who show dogs – most owners lose money showing their dogs. Showing is about the love of the breed. I’ve seen that for years and I wouldn’t report it that way if it weren’t true.

Imagine Madison Square Garden, full to the rafters, a few celebrities in plain view sitting amongst the crowd, many people in formal evening wear. The lights dim and the crowd goes wild as the spotlights follow the dogs trotting into the ring – and then your favorite breed enters and it’s almost as if it’s your own dog out there, vying for the big prize. When the Miniature Schnauzers take the ring, I know what it feels like to have a favorite football team, if only for a few minutes a year.

As usual, this year I’m rooting for the Miniature Schnauzers. Go Minis! What’s your favorite breed? Are you pro or anti dog shows? Why?

If you’re going to be at the Westminster Kennel Club Show, please send me a message on Facebook and let me know – I’ll make the time to meet you and say hi. And perhaps get you to root for the Mini Schnauzers with me too.

- More Mutterings -



4 of 7 Comments View All 7 Comments

Give us your opinion Give us your opinion on Westminster and The Puppy Bowl

User Avatar

Galadriel   Lothlorien, ME

2/22/2012 2:28:09 PM

Great article. I love pure bred dogs. I love mutts. I love DOGS! I think the shows are great for perfecting the breeds out there. And mutts are fun to have around to show the variety that dogs can produce. I'm pro breeding as long as it's responsible. And that goes for pure breds as well as

My first dog was the love of my life. She was a mix. My second dog is now an ancient pure bred from a top show line. I love her

The world wouldn't the same without all the different dogs. And who knows when the next mutt starts a new breed? Most of our "pure bred" dogs started out as mixes.

User Avatar

Aly   Hollister, CA

2/19/2012 12:56:36 AM

I <3 mutts too

User Avatar

Diane   Warrington, PA

2/17/2012 6:33:13 AM

I like both shows for different reasons. The puppies are really cute on the Puppy Bowl which is a family favorite each year! As for the Westminster Dog Show my only wish is they would show more of the Spitz dogs. Love American Eskimo, Keeshonds, Huskys, Malamutes etc. They never seem to win best in show that I have seen. These dogs are beautiful. As for pure breed vs mix I have only owned mix breed dogs and just love them! They have wonderful temperaments and they are beautiful dogs. So far I have had Beagle/Springer Spaniel mix (rescued as a pup at 3 mo) and two American Eskimo/Sheltie mixes. These dogs are all healthy and very happy pups. They are the light in my morning each day.

User Avatar

Fran   Stabhope, NJ

2/17/2012 6:09:50 AM

I love both shows for what they are. Westminister belongs to the purebred dogs-it's their time to sparkle.

The puppy bowl is endless love on four paws- there's nothing better and so entertaining for those hours.

Login to get points for commenting or write your comment below

First Name : Email :
International :
City : State :

Captcha Image

Get New Captcha

Top Products