New Orleans Mandatory Dog Spay-Neuter Scrapped

Ordinance for mandatory spay-neuter surgery withdrawn the day before vote.

Posted: November 10, 2009, 5 a.m. EST

New Orleans City Council member Cynthia Hedge-Morrell withdrew her mandatory spay-neuter and breeding restrictions proposal on late Nov. 4, a day before it was to be voted on by the full council.

Hedge-Morrell introduced the ordinance in September stating that the aim was to encourage pet owners to be responsible as well as help fund animal control operations.

The ordinance had been amended since the introduction to allow dog owners to have the choice of whether to keep their dog intact by paying an initial $30 permit application fee plus a $20 annual permit fee.

However, since the proposed fee must first be advertised to the public before the council can vote on it, the ordinance was withdrawn from the agenda, according to Joshua Barnett, director of communications, Office of Councilmember Cynthia Hedge-Morrell.

“We are going to use this time as an opportunity to get more info and input from breeders and veterinarians [to make this the best ordinance it can be],” Barnett said.

The ordinance, if enacted as written, would:

  • Require all dogs 6 months of age or older to be spayed or neutered. Owners who wish to keep their pets intact would need to purchase a breeder permit. A few exceptions are noted. For example, the dog is used by a government or law enforcement agency or an agent thereof for government, rescue, law enforcement or other government purposes.

  • Limit female dogs from having more than one litter per year, or having a litter if the female is younger than 18 months.

  • Permit the Louisiana SPCA, which will be responsible for enforcing the ordinance, to determine whether or not an applicant for a breeder license has “space determined to be suitable … in which to breed dogs and raise puppies.”

  • Impose fines for those who are found to be in violation of the ordinance.

A time frame as to when the topic would be revisited couldn’t be determined, according to Barnett.

The American Kennel Club has been strongly opposed to the ordinance and sent out a legislative alert on Nov. 2 urging dog breeders and owners to voice their opinion.

“The American Kennel Club opposes mandatory spay-neuter laws,” the AKC said in its alert. “Instead, we support reasonable and enforceable laws that protect the welfare and health of purebred dogs and do not restrict the rights of breeders and owners who take their responsibilities seriously.

“Additionally, we strongly support and actively promote a wide range of programs to educate the public about responsible breeding practices and the responsibilities of dog ownership.”

The AKC sent out an updated legislative alert on Nov. 5 stating that although the ordinance has been withdrawn, the AKC “continues to urge the City Council to study in-depth any existing animal population and enforcement funding issues that exist in New Orleans, and to work with all interested stakeholder groups in formulating reasonable and enforceable laws that protect public health and safety without harming those breeders and owners who take their responsibilities seriously.”

To read the ordinance, click here.


3 of 3 Comments View All 3 Comments

Give us your opinion Give us your opinion on New Orleans Mandatory Dog Spay-Neuter Scrapped

User Avatar

Galadriel   Lothlorien, ME

11/10/2009 10:18:17 PM

I am very glad that the bill has been stopped before even getting to the vote. It's unconstitutional and fanatical.

User Avatar

Isobella   Nashville, TN

11/10/2009 4:53:18 PM

The AKC really does not care for dogs. Nor does any breeder who's making a profit off of breeding or private citizen who is ignorant and stupid enough to think that while there are millions of animals dying because there are not enough responsible homes for them we should continue to breed more -both on purpose and indiscriminately. Any one or any group that opposes spay and nueter laws is a fool. If you think otherwise just go to your local animal control and see all the animals that are going to die because no one wants them. Do you want to indirectly be an enabler to this horrible situation? I certainly wouldn't.

And, last but not least, there is nothing "risky" or " unsafe" concerning spaying and nuetering before six months. Any complications are rare and are generally the fault of the owner for not keepng the incision clean and the animal quiet. All seven of my dogs and cats were done before six months with NO problem at all. What IS risky is a dog or cat giving birth - I've seen and heard of several dying.

User Avatar

Maggie   Lancaster, PA

11/10/2009 5:59:29 AM

Hopefully the delay will allow time to further oppose this bill!!!!!

There are Valid reasons to delay spay and neuter till after 6 mos. And they don't necessarily include breeding.

Responsible owners can keep a dog intact and not allow it to

There are valid reasons to breed a female two seasons in a row...reasons supported by knowledgeable veterinarians.

Making the SPCA responsible for determining who has the facilities to breed a litter...that's scary! Are they going to do a home inspection on every home who applies for a permit to keep their dog intact??? Not everyone asking for the exemption has plans to breed their dog anyway.

Login to get points for commenting or write your comment below

First Name : Email :
International :
City : State :

Captcha Image

Get New Captcha

Top Products