Does the Purebred Dog World Have a Death Wish?

With all that's going on, wouldn't you think that the show dog community would do its best to show a good face to the world? We need to do a much better job at public relations instead of wasting our time fighting with each other.

By Stephanie Hunt-Crowley |

Healthy Bulldog
Although the media often focus on the exaggerations of purebreds, responsible breeders do not sacrifice good health for pleasing conformation. In the case of the Bulldog breed, some of the top-winning dogs in the show ring boast health titles as well. Photo Gina Cioli/I-5 Studio.

This question has been asked for several years now, but in the beginning it seemed to be voices in the wilderness. The animal rights activists slid onto the scene in the 1980s, but we really did not notice that they were there, and it was not until the 1990s that their activism became obvious. Even so, their constant criticisms of dog breeders under the guise of attacking "puppy mills" created a divide in the dog show community itself. People were creating terms such as "responsible breeder" and "reputable breeder," and breeders who wanted to retain such badges of honor were expected follow certain codes of conduct to differentiate those breeders from the rest, the bad guys who deserved to be driven out of dogdom. In theory that sounded like a good idea, and members of the community fell in line. The problem was that there was no clear-cut definition, and pejorative descriptions were thrown around with abandon.

In the late 1990s, dog breeders saw the first attempted inroads on the control of dog breeding in general — and not just the "bad guys" — when the Doris Day Animal League made the first legislative attempt to force APHIS to make all dog breeders subject to the rules of the Animal Welfare Act. This failed — but we could already see how we were more interested in fighting with each other than fighting legislation! This was also the time when the Internet was gaining ground first with online bulletin boards and email groups where members could share and read comments made by people they had never met. There was an explosion both in speed of communication and the number of people that could be reached with the click of a mouse. As with any medium, whether it be newspaper or email group, there were people on both sides of the issue, and those in the middle were converted by one side or the other.

In the past 10 years, we have seen more and more legislation proposed and backed by the HSUS, all under the guise of clamping down on "puppy mills" — but with all of them creating serious problems for private breeders and show kennels, and even working and hunting dog breeders. Sadly, the show community was in almost total denial. "If you are not doing anything wrong, you have nothing to fear," was the reverberating response.

The tipping point came when California was presented with a state bill that would have mandated spay/neuter of all dogs and cats at 4 months of age. It failed, but the zealots did not give up. They grabbed hold of the media and harassed dog breeders, labeling all of us "the bad guys." The show community went into overdrive to show that "we" were the good guys by listing what a "good" breeder did or did not do and criticizing everyone else. Naturally, "good" breeders would never be affected by legislation, and cooperating with those on the unapproved list was tantamount to giving them the seal of approval.

"It is truly disturbing to read what people think about the show community. If they don't view us as evildoers breeding crippled dogs, they think of us as 'snobby show people.'"

Overpopulation was the big issue that was hammered home again and again, blaming dog breeders, even though the vast majority of dogs born were mixed breeds. Unwanted dogs were turned in to shelters and euthanized, and it was "our" fault. Now comes the third sucker punch — purebreds were depicted as deformed monstrosities bred for the show ring by uncaring breeders who used vile breeding methods such as inbreeding. Mixed Breeds were much healthier, of course, as they had "hybrid vigor."

With all of this going on, would you not think that the show dog community would do its best to show a good face to the world? I am not talking about organized events such as Westminster or Meet the Breeds. I mean people talking to people and showing the public that we are not all clones of Cruella De Vil! If you follow the comments sections on any news story about dogs and allow for the fact that many comments are written by paid hacks and trolls, it is truly disturbing to read what people think about the show community. If they don't view us as evildoers breeding crippled dogs, they think of us as "snobby show people" who do not want competition! The animal rights activists have done a good job of depicting us as the former, and we do a darned good job of presenting ourselves as the latter!

If someone calls a breeder and asks a politically incorrect question such as the price of a puppy, he or she is likely to have the phone slammed down on them — and then the breeders wonder why people end up going to a pet store. We have adopted the policy that we should never advertise; puppy buyers should appear magically when the Dog Show Fairy waves her wand, and they will then wait patiently for several months until their puppy is born. Anything less suggests an impulse buy, which is unacceptable.

The problem is, if we as a community never advertise, how does the public find out about different breeds? How do they learn that purebred dogs are not monstrosities and that many breeds are capable of doing many things? How do they learn the right way to raise and train a puppy if they end up with a mixed-breed puppy out of the Pennysaver? These people need to meet dog breeders, talk to them and go to dog shows just to see different breeds before making their choice. And we need to do a much better job at public relations instead of wasting our time fighting with each other.


From the August 2014 issue of Dogs in Review magazine. Subscribe to receive 12 months of Dogs in Review magazine, or call 1-888-738-2665 to purchase a single copy.


Read More

The Purebred Perception Problem
Purebred dogs and dog breeders are often seen in a negative light. Here's how you can change that perception. Read More>> 

Dog Handler Image More Important Than You Think
How handlers interact with the public and forge relationships with novices can hinder or help the future of the fancy. Read More>> 

The Purebred Dog Community Responds to HBO Real Sports' "Unnatural Selection" Segment
The Fancy Fires back against a biased report about purebred and show dog health on HBO's Real Sports with Bryant Gumbel, which aired on April 22, 2014. Read More>>


4 of 6 Comments View All 6 Comments

Give us your opinion Give us your opinion on Does the Purebred Dog World Have a Death Wish?

User Avatar

chris   St. Louis Park, Minnesota

9/22/2014 12:31:18 PM

Interesting in that we were using the term "reputable " breeder since about 1970 as we tried to educate the public to go direct to breeders for pups.

I do agree with the AR comments -- they are very much against breeding of any
We need to be the good guys

User Avatar

MCT   Mountain, ON

9/9/2014 10:55:10 AM

Just a question to Jemima posting on 8/29/14 ... are you the same Jemima of "Pedigree Dogs Exposed?"

User Avatar

Animal Lover   LA, California

8/29/2014 8:35:23 PM

Show people - breed your dogs to do what they were bred to do. Make sure your dogs are multi-talented, highly socialized, and you are a good OWNER!!! Don't fall into the crap of the ARses - don't use their language, don't fall for their myths, AND do everything you can, every time you can to educated JQP to just HOW GOOD our pure breds are, WHY are they better than mixed-breeds, and how your dogs fill your life!!!!!

User Avatar

Jemima   International

8/29/2014 12:24:50 AM

Oh, the irony of the caption on that Bulldog pic. There is nothing "pleasing" about this dog's conformation. The dog has stenotic nares, too big a nose roll (under which all that gunk lurks), awful front assembly and sore

Want to improve your PR? Acknowledge the problems and breed sounder dogs.

Login to get points for commenting or write your comment below

First Name : Email :
International :
City : State :

Captcha Image

Get New Captcha

Top Products